Logotipo Gazeta do Urubu
en
Soccer

FORMER REFEREE REPORTS EDINA ALVES' ERROR IN THE FLAMENGO X FORTALEZA MATCH

Rubro-Negro lost the game and the leadership of the Brasileirão

Edina Alves / Disclosure
Edina Alves / Disclosure

  |

Icon Comentário0

The clash between Flamengo and Fortaleza at Maracanã, last Thursday (11), was marked by refereeing controversies. One of the controversial decisions involved awarding a penalty to striker Pedro. Former referee Carlos Eugênio Simon harshly criticized referee Edina Alves' decision, stating that there was no foul in the move. According to Simon, Pedro kicked the wind, and the penalty should not have been awarded.

“Controversy at Maracanã. A penalty given to Flamengo that in my opinion didn't happen. Pedro ends up kicking the wind. It wasn't a penalty. The arbitration was wrong”, analyzed Simon on his social networks. The former referee's criticism quickly resonated among fans and analysts, increasing pressure on the refereeing team.


Edina Alves scored the penalty on the field and, after a VAR check, the decision was upheld . Another controversial move occurred in Fortaleza's first goal, when Flamengo players complained about a foul on Wesley. However, Paulo César de Oliveira, Globo commentator, defended the referee's decision not to award the foul, considering normal contact within the context of the game.


“This contact that we talk about is the reference contact, determining a distance. For me, it is an action that has no impact. If we change positions and put Wesley in Lucero's position, with the same contact, we definitely wouldn't call a foul. This contact is absolutely normal in the game. The goal was well confirmed”, analyzed Paulo César de Oliveira. The commentator's assessment reinforced the validity of Fortaleza's goal, despite red and black complaints.


The refereeing decisions generated a heated debate between experts and fans, dividing opinions about Edina Alves' performance and VAR. While some agreed with Paulo César de Oliveira's analysis, others aligned themselves with Carlos Eugênio Simon's criticism, highlighting the difficulty of interpreting controversial moves. The match, in addition to the result on the field, highlighted the importance and challenges of refereeing in Brazilian football.









Soccer

Check out Jorge Jesus' million-dollar fine in Saudi Arabia, speculated in Flamengo

Portuguese coach has had his name mentioned among candidates for election at the club

Jorge Jesus had his name speculated at Flamengo - Fran Santiago/Getty Images
Jorge Jesus had his name speculated at Flamengo - Fran Santiago/Getty Images

  |

Icon Comentário0

Flamengo has kept Jorge Jesus as a frequent target since the historic 2019 season. However, bringing him back, currently at Al-Hilal, would not be an easy task, especially due to the coach's high salary, which is among the highest paid in the world.

According to information from journalist Jorge Nicola, the termination fine to remove "Mister" from the Arab club is 40 million reais. Furthermore, it would be necessary to negotiate a new salary, as Jesus currently earns around 70 million reais per year, tax-free, which is equivalent to more than 6 million reais per month. The Portuguese's name resurfaced at Flamengo by candidates for election at the club.

If Flamengo or any other Brazilian club managed to sign him, Jesus would become the highest paid football coach on the continent, surpassing Abel Ferreira, coach from Palmeiras, who receives around 3 million reais per month.

Possible competition from the Brazilian team for Jorge Jesus

With Tite's situation uncertain to lead Flamengo in 2025, Jorge Jesus' name begins to be mentioned behind the scenes. However, the Brazilian team could also enter the dispute for the coach. Despite the recent arrival of Dorival Júnior at the helm of the national team, there is suspicion within the CBF about the continuity of his work.

Therefore, Jorge Jesus becomes a coveted target for both Flamengo and the Brazilian team, both of whom are aware that they will have to make a considerable investment if they want to rely on the technician.




Soccer

Journalist says Flamengo is dead

Rubro-Negro finds itself at the moment of greatest instability in the season

Reproduction
Reproduction

  |

Icon Comentário0

Since the beginning of the year, competing in all possible competitions, Flamengo has faced a series of problems in the final stretch of the season due to wear and tear. Injuries and the need to save players have caused headaches for Tite, a situation that, according to André Rizek, should not happen.

For the journalist, Flamengo has a squad deep enough to rotate the team. He believes that Tite could have rotated more throughout the season to, at this point, have more players in ideal physical condition. Rizek cited the game against Grêmio as an example, where Mengão, even with a completely modified team, played good football despite the defeat.


“Flamengo has reached a point in the season where the team is so hurt , so tired... It's clear. You see Flamengo play, the team is dead. I would have done the same (save against Grêmio). Yesterday's game (Sunday, 22nd) is a sign that Flamengo could have rotated the squad a little more during the season. Flamengo's C team had a good performance against Grêmio", said the commentator.


Rizek states that Flamengo did not fight for the Brasileirão title

Even two-time champion in 2019 and 2020, André Rizek criticized Flamengo for not fighting adequately for the Brasileirão in recent years. He argues that the team has a qualified and abundant squad to compete in both cups and the points championship, but has chosen to focus more on knockout competitions.


“Flamengo, with the squad that There is, it's a team to fight for the Brasileirão title every year and for four years, in this final stretch of the championship, it has been distant. In all these years, Flamengo has dealt with such a great sense of urgency in the cups that the Brazilian Championship is like this... it didn't work”, he assessed.

This season, Flamengo even led the Brasileirão for a few rounds, but stumbles, greatly influenced by the preservation and wear and tear of the players, ended up damaging Rubro-Negro's chances of remaining at the top of the table.



Soccer

CBF RELEASES AUDIO OF THE VIDEO REFEREE IN PÊNLATI SCHEDULED FOR FLAMENGO, AT A CONTROVERSIAL TIME

'The player's thigh prevents the attacker from shooting the ball', said the VAR to the person in charge Edina Alves

VAR CBF/ Disclosure
VAR CBF/ Disclosure

  |

Icon Comentário0


The CBF released, this Friday morning, the VAR audios of the match between Flamengo and Fortaleza, which was marked by controversy. The penalty awarded in favor of the red-black club, in the first half, generated a lot of complaints from Leão players. However, the video referee maintained the decision on the field, intensifying the controversy surrounding the move.



In the 35th minute of the first half, striker Pedro was brought down by Pedro Augusto inside the area. Referee Edina Alves promptly awarded the penalty and VAR, led by Caio Max Augusto Vieira, reviewed the play. After analysis, Vieira agreed with the initial appointment. The decision caused dissatisfaction among Fortaleza players, who contested the lack of a more careful review.



The controversial move occurred when the red-black striker was preparing to kick and received a subtle touch from behind the tricolor player. In the released recordings, it is possible to hear the discussion between the referees about the intensity of the touch and its influence on Pedro's fall. The consensus was that the contact was sufficient to justify the penalty being awarded, despite Fortaleza's complaints.



The release of the audios by VAR was an attempt by the CBF to clarify the decision and increase transparency in the arbitration process. The measure, however, divided opinions between fans and experts, with some defending the referees' interpretation and others criticizing the lack of consistency in similar moves. The controversy reinforces the need for continuous improvement in the use of technology in Brazilian football.


The match ended with Fortaleza's victory, but discussions about refereeing overshadowed the final result. The release of audios by VAR highlights the growing pressure for greater clarity and precision in decisions that directly influence the outcome of games. The CBF remains committed to improving the use of VAR, seeking to minimize errors and increase fairness in national football.



< br>



< /p>


envelopeSUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER

envelopeSUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER


+ news
Soccer

SporTV commentators express pessimism about Flamengo's end of season

 

Icon Comentário0
Soccer

Flamengo's creation openly declares himself to Corinthians and says that the Paulista club was the main one in his career

 

Icon Comentário0
Soccer

Not long! Flamengo plans date for Michael's return to the pitch - check it out

 

Icon Comentário0